NAME

dcmicmp - Compare DICOM images and compute difference metrics

SYNOPSIS

dcmicmp [options] dcmfile-in-1 dcmfile-in-2

DESCRIPTION

The dcmicmp utility reads two DICOM images, an original 'reference image' and a post-processed 'test image', to which some kind of processing such as a lossy image compression, followed by decompression, has been applied. This tool requires that both images have the same resolution, the same number of frames and are either both color or monochrome. Compressed images are not supported.

The dcmicmp utility then compares both images and computes and prints metrics that describe how similar or different both images are:

the maximum absolute error is the largest difference between an pixel value in the reference image and the corresponding pixel value in the test image.
the mean absolute error (MAE) is the average difference between original pixel value and test image pixel value
the root mean square error (RMSE) is computed by adding the squares of all difference values, then dividing by the number of values added, and then taking the square root.
The peak signal to noise ratio (PSNR) considers the reference image as a signal and the differences between reference and test image as noise. PSNR is the maximum signal strength (i.e. maximum pixel value in the reference image) divided by the RMSE, expressed on a logarithmic scale in dB.
The signal to noise ratio (PSNR) also considers the reference image as a signal and the differences between reference and test image as noise. SNR is the average signal strength divided by the RMSE, expressed on a logarithmic scale in dB.

All metrics are computed as defined in R.C. Gonzalez and R.E. Woods, 'Digital Image Processing,' Prentice Hall 2008.

PARAMETERS

dcmfile-in-1  Reference DICOM image file for comparison
dcmfile-in-2  Test DICOM image file for comparison

OPTIONS

general options

  -h    --help
          print this help text and exit
        --version
          print version information and exit
        --arguments
          print expanded command line arguments
  -q    --quiet
          quiet mode, print no warnings and errors
  -v    --verbose
          verbose mode, print processing details
  -d    --debug
          debug mode, print debug information
  -ll   --log-level  [l]evel: string constant
          (fatal, error, warn, info, debug, trace)
          use level l for the logger
  -lc   --log-config  [f]ilename: string
          use config file f for the logger

input options

input file format:
  +f    --read-file
          read file format or data set (default)
  +fo   --read-file-only
          read file format only
  -f    --read-dataset
          read data set without file meta information
input transfer syntax:
  -t=   --read-xfer-auto
          use TS recognition (default)
  -td   --read-xfer-detect
          ignore TS specified in the file meta header
  -te   --read-xfer-little
          read with explicit VR little endian TS
  -tb   --read-xfer-big
          read with explicit VR big endian TS
  -ti   --read-xfer-implicit
          read with implicit VR little endian TS

image processing options

modality LUT transformation:
  +M    --use-modality
          use modality LUT transformation (default)
  -M    --no-modality
          ignore stored modality LUT transformation
VOI LUT transformation:
  -W    --no-windowing
          no VOI windowing (default)
  +Wi   --use-window  [n]umber: integer
          use the n-th VOI window from image file
  +Wl   --use-voi-lut  [n]umber: integer
          use the n-th VOI look up table from image file
  +Wm   --min-max-window
          compute VOI window using min-max algorithm
          on both images separately
  +Wn   --min-max-window-n
          compute VOI window using min-max algorithm
          on both images separately, ignoring extremes
  +Wr   --min-max-ref
          compute VOI window using min-max algorithm
          and use same window for the test image
  +Wq   --min-max-n-ref
          compute VOI window using min-max algorithm,
          ignoring extreme values
          and use same window for the test image
  +Ww   --set-window  [c]enter [w]idth: float
          compute VOI window using center c and width w
  +Wfl  --linear-function
          set VOI LUT function to LINEAR
  +Wfs  --sigmoid-function
          set VOI LUT function to SIGMOID
presentation LUT transformation:
  +Pid  --identity-shape
          set presentation LUT shape to IDENTITY
  +Piv  --inverse-shape
          set presentation LUT shape to INVERSE
  +Pod  --lin-od-shape
          set presentation LUT shape to LIN OD

image comparison metrics options

  +ce   --check-error  [l]imit: integer
          check if max absolute error <= limit
  # Return exit code EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_MAX_ERROR if the computed
  # maximum absolute error is larger than the given limit.
  +cm   --check-mae  [l]imit: float
          check if mean absolute error <= limit
  # Return exit code EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_MAE if the computed
  # mean absolute error is larger than the given limit.
  +cr   --check-rmse  [l]imit: float
          check if root mean square error <= limit
  # Return exit code EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_RMSE if the computed
  # root mean square error is larger than the given limit.
  +cp   --check-psnr  [l]imit: float
          check if PSNR >= limit
  # Return exit code EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_PSNR if the computed
  # peak signal to noise ratio is smaller than the given limit
  # (for PSNR, higher values mean better image quality)
  +cs   --check-snr  [l]imit: float
          check if SNR >= limit
  # Return exit code EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_PSNR if the computed
  # signal to noise ratio is smaller than the given limit
  # (for SNR, higher values mean better image quality)

output options

  +sd   --save-diff  [f]ilename: string
          write secondary capture difference image
  # Create a Multiframe Secondary Capture image that contains a
  # difference image between reference and test image. For monochrome
  # images, one difference frame is created for each frame in the reference
  # image. For color images, three monochrome frames are created for each
  # frame in the reference image, corresponding to the differences in the
  # red, green and blue color plane. The difference image will have
  # BitsStored 8 or 16, depending on the properties of the reference image.
  +a    --amplify  [f]actor: float
          multiply diff image pixel values by f
  # This option can be used to amplify the grayscale values in the
  # difference image by multiplying each value with the given factor.
  # Alternatively, a DICOM VOI LUT window may be used when visualizing
  # the difference image.

NOTES

grayscale display pipeline

Monochrome DICOM images require that a multi-stage display pipeline is executed in order to convert the raw pixel values to the so-called presentation values (p-values) that are sent to the (possibly calibrated) display. When comparing the similarity of images before and after post-processing, it can be relevant to activate some stages of this display pipeline before calculating the difference image and metrics. The image processing options allow the caller to either activate or deactivate the Modality LUT, VOI LUT and Presentation LUT transformations. In any case, the same transformation is applied to both images, although possibly with different parameters if for example the 'first VOI LUT window' stored in each image is applied. This assumes that the post-processing algorithm (e.g. compression algorithm) has adapted the values of such windows during compression such that the image display after applying the window is as close as possible to the reference. For images with more than 8 bits/sample it may be important to known which VOI LUT transformation will be applied by the user when viewing the image, because this may affect the perceived image quality. Therefore, absolute Window parameters can also be given with the --set-window option, which will then be applied to both images.

suitability of images for diagnostic purposes

The user should also note that the metrics computed by this tool cannot predict or estimate the suitability of lossy compressed image for diagnostic purposes. Much more complex image processing and an understanding of the image content (e.g. body part) would be needed for this purpose. The metrics computed provide an estimation of the level of distortion caused by the post-processing - no more and no less.

TRANSFER SYNTAXES

dcmicmp supports the following transfer syntaxes for input:

LittleEndianImplicitTransferSyntax             1.2.840.10008.1.2
LittleEndianExplicitTransferSyntax             1.2.840.10008.1.2.1
DeflatedExplicitVRLittleEndianTransferSyntax   1.2.840.10008.1.2.1.99 (*)
BigEndianExplicitTransferSyntax                1.2.840.10008.1.2.2

The difference image file is always written in Little Endian Implicit Transfer Syntax.

(*) if compiled with zlib support enabled

LOGGING

The level of logging output of the various command line tools and underlying libraries can be specified by the user. By default, only errors and warnings are written to the standard error stream. Using option --verbose also informational messages like processing details are reported. Option --debug can be used to get more details on the internal activity, e.g. for debugging purposes. Other logging levels can be selected using option --log-level. In --quiet mode only fatal errors are reported. In such very severe error events, the application will usually terminate. For more details on the different logging levels, see documentation of module 'oflog'.

In case the logging output should be written to file (optionally with logfile rotation), to syslog (Unix) or the event log (Windows) option --log-config can be used. This configuration file also allows for directing only certain messages to a particular output stream and for filtering certain messages based on the module or application where they are generated. An example configuration file is provided in <etcdir>/logger.cfg.

COMMAND LINE

All command line tools use the following notation for parameters: square brackets enclose optional values (0-1), three trailing dots indicate that multiple values are allowed (1-n), a combination of both means 0 to n values.

Command line options are distinguished from parameters by a leading '+' or '-' sign, respectively. Usually, order and position of command line options are arbitrary (i.e. they can appear anywhere). However, if options are mutually exclusive the rightmost appearance is used. This behavior conforms to the standard evaluation rules of common Unix shells.

In addition, one or more command files can be specified using an '@' sign as a prefix to the filename (e.g. @command.txt). Such a command argument is replaced by the content of the corresponding text file (multiple whitespaces are treated as a single separator unless they appear between two quotation marks) prior to any further evaluation. Please note that a command file cannot contain another command file.

EXIT CODES

The dcmicmp utility uses the following exit codes when terminating. This enables the user to check for the reason why the application terminated.

general

EXITCODE_NO_ERROR                         0
EXITCODE_COMMANDLINE_SYNTAX_ERROR         1

input/output file errors

EXITCODE_INVALID_INPUT_FILE              22
EXITCODE_CANNOT_WRITE_OUTPUT_FILE        40

image processing errors

EXITCODE_INITIALIZE_DIFF_IMAGE           80
EXITCODE_DISPLAY_PIPELINE                81
EXITCODE_IMAGE_COMPARISON                82

error codes for exceeded limits

EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_MAX_ERROR        90
EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_MAE              91
EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_RMSE             92
EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_PSNR             93
EXITCODE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED_SNR              94

ENVIRONMENT

The dcmicmp utility will attempt to load DICOM data dictionaries specified in the DCMDICTPATH environment variable. By default, i.e. if the DCMDICTPATH environment variable is not set, the file <datadir>/dicom.dic will be loaded unless the dictionary is built into the application (default for Windows).

The default behavior should be preferred and the DCMDICTPATH environment variable only used when alternative data dictionaries are required. The DCMDICTPATH environment variable has the same format as the Unix shell PATH variable in that a colon (':') separates entries. On Windows systems, a semicolon (';') is used as a separator. The data dictionary code will attempt to load each file specified in the DCMDICTPATH environment variable. It is an error if no data dictionary can be loaded.