NAME

Math::Evol - Evolution search optimisation

SYNOPSIS

 use Math::Evol;
 ($xbref,$smref,$fb,$lf) = evol(\@xb,\@sm,\&function,\&constrain,$tm);
 # or
 ($xbref, $smref) = select_evol(\@xb,\@sm,\&choose_best,\&constrain);
 # or
 $new_text = text_evol($text, \&choose_best_text, $nchoices );

DESCRIPTION

This module implements the evolution search strategy. Derivatives of the objective function are not required. Constraints can be incorporated. The caller must supply initial values for the variables and for the initial step sizes.

This evolution strategy is a random strategy, and as such is particularly robust and will cope well with large numbers of variables, or rugged objective funtions.

Evol.pm works either automatically (evol) with an objective function to be minimised, or interactively (select_evol) with a (suitably patient) human who at each step will choose the better of two possibilities. Another subroutine (text_evol) allows the evolution of numeric parameters in a text file, the parameters to be varied being identified in the text by means of special comments. A script ps_evol which uses that is included for human-judgement-based fine-tuning of drawings in PostScript.

Version 1.13

SUBROUTINES

evol(\@xb, \@sm, \&minimise, \&constrain, $tm);

Where the arguments are: @xb the initial values of variables, @sm the initial values of step sizes, &minimise the function to be minimised, &constrain a function constraining the values, $tm the max allowable cpu time in seconds

The step sizes and the caller-supplied functions &function and &constrain are discussed below. The default value of $tm is 10 seconds.

evol returns a list of four things: \@xb the best values of the variables, \@sm the final values of step sizes, $fb the best value of objective function, $lf a success parameter

$lf is set false if the search ran out of cpu time before converging. For more control over the convergence criteria, see the CONVERGENCE CRITERIA section below.

select_evol(\@xb, \@sm, \&choose_best, \&constrain, $nchoices);

Where the arguments are: @xb the initial values of variables, @sm the initial values of step sizes, &choose_best the function allowing the user to select the best, &constrain a function constraining the values, $nchoices the number of choices select_evol generates

The step sizes and the caller-supplied functions &choose_best and &constrain are discussed below. $nchoices is the number of alternative choices which will be offered to the user, in addition to the current best array of values. The default value of $nchoices is 1, giving the user the choice between the current best and 1 alternative.

select_evol returns a list of two things: \@xb the best values of the variables, and \@sm the final values of step sizes

text_evol( $text, \&choose_best_text, $nchoices );

The $text is assumed to contain some numeric parameters to be varied, marked out by magic comments which also supply initial step sizes for them, and optionally also maxima and minima. For example:

 $x = -2.3456; # evol step .1
 /x 3.4567 def % evol step .2
 /gray_sky .87 def % evol step 0.05 min 0.0 max 1.0

The magic bit of the comment is evol step and the previous number on the same line is taken as the value to be varied. The function reference \&choose_best_text is discussed below. $nchoices gets passed by text_evol directly to select_evol.

&text_evol returns the optimised $text.

&text_evol is intended for fine-tuning of PostScript, or files specifying GUI's, or HTML layout, or StyleSheets, or MIDI, where the value judgement must be made by a human being. As an example, a script called ps_evol for fine-tuning A4 PostScript drawings is included with this package; it uses $nchoices = 8 and puts the nine alternatives onto one A4 page which the user can then view with Ghostview in order to select the best one.

STEP SIZES

The caller must supply initial values for the step sizes. Following the work of Rechenberg and of Schwefel, evol will adjust these step-sizes as it proceeds to give a success rate of about 0.2, but since the ratios between the step-sizes remain constant, it helps convergence to supply sensible values.

A good rule of thumb is the expected distance of the value from its optimum divided by the square root of the number of variables. Larger step sizes increase the chance of discovering a global optimum rather than an inferior local optimum, at the cost of course of slower convergence.

CALLER-SUPPLIED SUBROUTINES

minimise( @x );

evol minimises an objective funtion; that function accepts a list of values and returns a numerical scalar result. For example,

 sub minimise {   # objective function, to be minimised
    my $sum; foreach (@_) { $sum += $_*$_; }  # sigma x**2
    return $sum;
 }
 ($xbref, $smref, $fb, $lf) = evol (\@xb, \@sm, \&minimise);

constrain( @x );

You may also supply a subroutine constrain(@x) which forces the variables to have acceptable values. If you do not wish to constrain the values, just pass 0 instead. constrain(@x) should return the list of the acceptable values. For example,

 sub constrain {   # force values into acceptable range
    if ($_[0]>1.0) { $_[0]=1.0;  # it's a probability
    } elsif ($_[0]<0.0) { $_[0]=0.0;
    }
    my $cost = 3.45*$_[1] + 4.56*$_[2] + 5.67*$_[3];
    if ($cost > 1000.0) {  # enforce 1000 dollars maximum cost
       $_[1]*=1000/$cost; $_[2]*=1000/$cost; $_[3]*=1000/$cost;
    }
    if ($_[4]<0.0) { $_[4]=0.0; }  # it's a population density
    $_[5] = int ($_[5] + 0.5);     # it's an integer
    return @_;
 }
 ($xbref,$smref,$fb,$lf) = evol (\@xb,\@sm,\&minimise,\&constrain);

choose_best( \@a, \@b, \@c ... );

This function whose reference is passed to select_evol must accept a list of array_refs; the first ref refers to the current array of values, and the others refer to alternative arrays of values. The user should then judge which of the arrays is best, and choose_best must then return ($preference, $continue) where $preference is the index of the preferred array_ref (0, 1, etc). The other argument ($continue) is set false if the user thinks the optimal result has been arrived at; this is select_evol's only convergence criterion. For example,

 use Term::Clui;
 sub choose_best { my ($aref, $bref) = @_;
    inform("Array 0 is @$aref");
    inform("Array 1 is @$bref");
    my $preference = 0 + choose('Do you prefer 0 or 1 ?','0','1');
    my $continue   = confirm('Continue ?');
    return ($preference, $continue);
 }
 ($xbref, $smref, $fb, $lf) = select_evol(\@xb, \@sm, \&choose_best);

choose_best_text( $text1, $text2, $text3 ... );

This function whose reference is passed to text_evol must accept a list of text strings; the first will contain the current values while the others contain alternative values. The user should then judge which of the strings produces the best result. choose_best_text must return ($preference, $continue) where $preference is the index of the preferred string (0, 1, etc). The other argument ($continue) is set false if the user thinks the optimal result has been arrived at; this is text_evol's only convergence criterion.

As an example, see the script called ps_evol for fine-tuning A4 PostScript drawings which is included with this package.

CONVERGENCE CRITERIA

$ec (>0.0) is the convergence test, absolute. The search is terminated if the distance between the best and worst values of the objective function within the last 25 trials is less than or equal to $ec. The absolute convergence test is suppressed if $ec is undefined.

$ed (>0.0) is the convergence test, relative. The search is terminated if the difference between the best and worst values of the objective function within the last 25 trials is less than or equal to $ed multiplied by the absolute value of the objective function. The relative convergence test is suppressed if $ed is undefined.

These interact with two other small numbers $ea and $eb, which are the minimum allowable step-sizes, absolute and relative respectively.

These number are set within Math::Evol as follows:

 $ea = 0.00000000000001;   # absolute stepsize
 $eb = 0.000000001;        # relative stepsize
 $ec = 0.0000000000000001; # absolute error
 $ed = 0.00000000001;      # relative error

You can change those settings before invoking the evol subroutine, e.g.:

 $Math::Evol::ea = 0.00000000000099;   # absolute stepsize
 $Math::Evol::eb = 0.000000042;        # relative stepsize
 undef $Math::Evol::ec;  # disable absolute-error-criterion
 $Math::Evol::ec = 0.0000000000000031; # absolute error
 $Math::Evol::ed = 0.00000000067;      # relative error

The most robust criterion is the maximum-cpu-time parameter $tm

LUA

In the "lua/" subdirectory of the install directory there is Evol.lua, which is an exact translation of this Perl code into Lua. The function names and arguments are unchanged, except that text_evol is not yet implemented. Brief Synopsis:

 local M = require 'Evol'
 local function minimise(x) -- returns a number to be minimised
    local sum = 1.0
    for k,v in pairs(x) do sum = sum + v * v end
    return sum
 end
 local function constrain(x)
    if x[1] > 1.0 then x[1] = 1.0  -- it's a greyscale value
    elseif x[1] < 0.0 then x[1] = 0.0
    end
    return x
 end
 local function choose_best(arglist)
    local preference = 1; local i_arg
    for i_arg=1,#arglist do
       local x = arglist[i_arg]
       if that_suits_me() then preference = i_arg; break end
    end
    local continue   = true or false
    return preference, continue
 end
 M.ed = 0.00000000067                       -- relative error
 local x  = {3.456, 1.234, -2.345, 4.567}  -- starting values
 local sm = {.8, .4, .6, 1.2}          -- starting step-sizes
 local tm = 5.0                        -- max time in seconds

 -- and now...
 xb,sm,fb,lf = M.evol(xb, sm, minimise, constrain, tm)
 -- or
 xb,sm = M.select_evol(xb, sm, choose_best, constrain)

 -- not yet implemented :
 -- new_text = M.text_evol(text, choose_best_text, nchoices)

AUTHOR

Peter J Billam, www.pjb.com.au/comp/contact.html

CREDITS

The strategy of adjusting the step-size to give a success rate of 0.2 comes from the work of I. Rechenberg in his Optimisation of Technical Systems in Accordance with the Principles of Biological Evolution (Problemata Series, Vol. 15, Verlag Fromman-Holzboog, Stuttgart 1973).

The code of evol is based on the Fortran version in Numerical Optimisation of Computer Models by Hans-Paul Schwefel, Wiley 1981, pp 104-117, 330-337, translated into english by M.W. Finnis from Numerische Optimierung von Computer-Modellen mittels der Evolutionsstrategie (Interdiscipliniary Systems Research, Vol. 26), Birkhaeuser Verlag, Basel 1977. The calling interface has been greatly Perlised, and the constraining of values has been much simplified.